Advice: AWD or no

[dnoone]

Need some input on AWD. Does the 3 series AWD provide an appreciable difference in handling road conditions? I live in the northeast and have had AWD on other, lesser nameplates that I've owned and have had mixed feelings on the value...curious what bimmer pros think. Thanks.

 

[codex57]

The 3 series BMW AWD version isn't the best in class, but owners seem to report satisfaction with it. I have no personal experience with them though since I live in California.

 

[dschwartzer]

I just leased a 325xiT wagon which has AWD. The information I got and the research I did, was that the AWD gives better handling than the RWD in bad weather. In dry conditions there is not much difference.

This car replaced a Subaru Outback wagon with AWD so I was looking for an AWD vehicle.

I haven't had any real bad weather yet (I'm in CT) but I have been on some wet/slick roads and I think the car has handled very well.

 

[SpeedPhreak]

i just bought an 88ix & LOVE it. i havent had bad weather yet either but have had some "spirtited" moments in the mountains. i have yet to break it loose or feel no confidence in the car. i cant wait for some snow so i can go play in an empty parking lot.

i know my awd system is 16yrs older than what u r looking at.. but there is no way it would have gotten worse.

 

[HornyHornet]

BMW AWD = 62% rear/38% front. System is called xDrive. Some what capable system but mainly designed to maintain RWD feel. All xi's are about and inch higher. Subaru AWD is more true AWD.

 

[codex57]

Is it xDrive? I thought that was on the SAV's, but not on the 3 series. Thought the 3 series system was slightly more simple.

 

[Average Jae]

the first gen xi had the first gen xDrive, which i think was derived from the x5's system, where the split was fixed 62 rear, 38 front.

when they came out w/ the x3, they revised the xDrive so torque wouldn't be fixed at 38/62 split. the torque could be delivered to the wheel w/ most traction, or something like that, and the x5 starting 04 has that system.

anyway, i heard that they'll be phasing out the xi in favor of the x3. or was it just the XiT?

either way, if you want a awd ride, audi has one of the best awd systems. but test drive teh xi, the quatro, and maybe even the saab 9-2 among other rides before deciding. how much are you looking to spend?

 

[epj3]

Actually the new x-drive (on the new x3) can provide 100% of the power to ONE single wheel. I'll find you all the link tomorrow, i'm really tired...hehe

 

[Chesty Bonds]

While AWD is definitely safer and in driving up to 8/10ths of the car's capability there is no discernible difference in the handling it is in the last 2/10ths where the AWD loses out to the RWD. It's the inherent understeer (and extra weight) which robs it of challenging the handling dynamics of a rear-driver.

Go RWD every time.

 

[330i and like it]

In the snow the 330i RWD can be a little beast. The back end with get away from you if tou give it gas, 4WD has is the way you need to go.
Mark
www.castle-designs-inc.com