Did I get duped by my mechanic?

dj_kim

New Member
Messages
6
Likes
0
Location
Korea
#1
Hi!

Although I've been driving a car for more than a decade (not always a BMW), I'm not well versed in the mechanical aspect of a car.

Recently, I had taken my 528 (E39) to the nearest certified mechanic here in Korea to check the brakes, after hearing metallic sound coming from the brake. Upon inspection, the mechanic told me that they could do some "sanding" (This is what they told me) which would reduce the metallic sound, although the sound was not due to thinned brake lining. I requested "sanding".

But what they said would take 30 minutes turned into an hour and a half and the mechanic came to me and told me there was a problem. They said they found the "boot" that covered the "calliper" was torn and had to be replaced. When I asked them what caused the damage, they just said it was not clear what caused it.

Now, although I don't want to be accusing, I cannot but suspect if they somehow tore the "boot" and duped me. There had been no sign of brake oil leakage when I took the car to the mechanic.

Is it possible that the "boot" can be torn from normal driving? I've even secured the "boot" in case I need to produce it as evidence in a legal proceeding.


(The quotationed terms used above may not be the correct terms. I just wrote what I think I heard. According to the mechanic's explanation, the "boot" is the piece of rubber that covers the calliper. Calliper is what moves the brake back and forth.)

I would really apreciate your opinions on this matter.
 
Messages
156
Likes
0
Location
Urbana
#2
I would think it would be very easy for a rock or other road debris to get thrown up and tear the rubber caliper boot. Or just dry rot could have weakened it. If it was torn, and water or other debris got inside, it could have been causing the noise you were hearing.
 
Messages
220
Likes
0
Location
Peoria, AZ
#3
It sounds like he was trying to "de-glaze" the rotors and pads. This means that the contact surface of the pads and rotors somehow became polished and probably began to make a noise. This can happen from riding the brakes, or going down hilly or mountanious roads.

It is possible to over look a torn caliper boot until you disassemble the brakes for this procedure-it is also possible to accidently rip it in the process of tearing down the brakes to de-glaze them.

I'm sorry if this wasn't much help, but there is really no way to know which happened.
You just have to trust your mechanic, or find one that you can trust and stick with them.
 
Messages
42
Likes
0
Location
Vancouver, BC Canada
#4
He could have torn it removing the brakes to de glaze, but it's not likely. It is more likely that the rubber boot just dried out and ended up tearing. That is very common on older calipers and is not a major deal to replace. If you DON'T replace it, moisture will get in there and etch the piston which would require you to replace the caliper. Caliper replacement is MUCH more money than just rebuilding/replacing the dust boot. [driving]
 

dj_kim

New Member
Messages
6
Likes
0
Location
Korea
#5
Cost of replacing dust boot in Korea

"That is very common on older calipers and is not a major deal to replace."

But it was a major deal for me. It cost equivalent to US $400.
Besides, I'm not sure if my E39, considering it's not an old model, has older calipers.
 
Messages
1,165
Likes
2
Location
Houston, Texas
#8
Welcome aboard the BMW forum.........I enjoyed Seoul.........I know I'm spelling it incorrectly, but really loved Ittiwan (shopping district).......post some pics of your ride....
 

dj_kim

New Member
Messages
6
Likes
0
Location
Korea
#9
I think that's written as Itaewon.
My car is a run-of-the-mill 528 (now so common in Seoul), I don't think you'll be thrilled to see my ride.
I'll put up a photo soon, though.
 


Top